When I read the news this morning that Heidi and Frank are charging for their new show, I was like…hm…that sucks. I won’t be listening to them anymore. No tears, no drama, no complaining, no angst, no pounding of fists. Just…hm…that sucks.
And then I spent the day thinking about why I didn’t even consider paying for a VIP membership.
Yes, I can ‘afford’ $5 a month. I can ‘afford’ lots of things I don’t buy.
I can ‘afford’ to buy a pack of cigarettes every month – but I don’t smoke. I can ‘afford’ a trip to Chuck E. Cheese every month – but I’d rather not torture myself.
I can ‘afford’ to buy a jar of blueberry preserves from Trader Joe’s every month. And I love Trader Joe’s blueberry preserves – delicious in sandwiches, on toast, in greek yogurt parfaits. (Seriously, you should buy some next time you’re there.) But I don’t buy blueberry preserves every month. Why not? Because it’s just not something I think about much. It’s not that important to me.
I’m rational enough to realize that people who do good work deserve to be paid. I don’t share my Netflix username/password. I always pay for my music downloads. I’m happy to throw some money at Randy and Gina when I can.
But paying for the Heidi and Frank Show makes me feel a little bit sick. I’ve narrowed it down to these reasons:
(Bulleted list especially for Therese.)
- Heidi and Frank didn’t mention the pay thing at all – until today.
- Whoever is running their show’s Facebook page is bullying people with – C’mon, $5? Seriously?! Give up your latte! Funny how there’s sooo much support until we ask you to pay! REAL fans will pay! Frankly, I’d prefer a little NPR-style guilt trip more than straight-out bullying.
- Their new website. I don’t know how to describe it exactly. It’s just like…skeezy or something, vaguely porn-ish in a ‘Watch one minute free – give us your credit card number to see more’ way.
I certainly want podcasting to be successful. I’ve willingly supported lots of Internet radio shows and podcasts in the last year and a half. But this Heidi and Frank thing…it just doesn’t feel right to me.
And, if I learned anything from Dr. Laura, it’s this. If it feels good, do it!
(Wait, that might not be right…)
